[ARFC] Aave Protocol Bug Bounty Programs Restructure

Summary

LlamaRisk supports the proposed restructuring of the Aave DAO bug bounty framework into separate subsystem programs. This approach offers operational and risk-management benefits that the current framework does not sufficiently cover. By using dedicated scopes, diversified bounty platforms, and isolated risk profiling, the assessment accounts for varying architectural designs and risk severities without forcing an aggregated risk ordering. Aggregating uncorrelated risks would misalign stakeholder incentives.

We agree with the progressive approach to determining whether a consolidated framework or the multiple-platform approach serves Aave’s best interests. The goal of this restructuring and any future adjustments should ensure sufficient coverage for the Aave ecosystem.

Multiple Platforms

The proposed 6-12 month assessment window for the different platforms is prudent. Understanding the tradeoffs will allow Aave to make data-driven decisions about whether consolidation or multiple bounties is more beneficial.

Payout Framework

In line with our bug bounty analysis, the maximum bounties on offer in each scope exceed the minimum $50K threshold we recommend. Each scope’s payout increases progressively relative to its TVL, with Aave V3 having the highest max payout, given it currently represents the largest share of liquidity. This aligns with the best practices we believe all programs should follow.

Additionally, the different severity payouts increase at a reasonable rate, without creating excessive incentive gaps between different severity levels.

Scope Coverage

In addition to core smart contracts covered under each program, we encourage the inclusion of non-liquidity protocol infrastructure. This includes applications, domains, and Aave products, ensuring comprehensive coverage of all potential vectors that could expose the protocol to risk. In our view, an effective security framework should address risks across all layers of the ecosystem, including but not limited to:

  • Loss or unauthorized transfer of user funds
  • Exposure of private keys, credentials, or other sensitive data
  • Unauthorized disclosure of user information
  • Execution of unauthorized or misleading state-modifying actions
  • Domain takeovers, DNS compromise, or malicious redirections

Disclaimer

This review was independently prepared by LlamaRisk, a DeFi risk service provider funded in part by the Aave DAO. LlamaRisk is not directly affiliated with the protocol(s) reviewed in this assessment and did not receive any compensation from the protocol(s) or their affiliated entities for this work.

The information provided should not be construed as legal, financial, tax, or professional advice.