[ARFC] - Chaos Labs Risk Stewards - Increase Supply and Borrow Caps on V3 Metis - 09.20.2023

Summary

A proposal to increase:

  • m.USDC - supply and borrow cap
  • m.USDT - supply and borrow cap
  • WETH - borrow cap
  • METIS - supply cap

Motivation

Following the launch of the Metis Incentive Program on Aave, which currently incentivizes borrowing of all Metis-listed assets as well as the supply of METIS and WETH, we’ve observed full utilization of the supply caps and a significant utilization of borrow caps.

While the program has driven increased usage, it’s worth noting that a substantial portion of this activity involves users looping the same asset to capture yield. Below, we provide recommendations for increasing some of these caps below after analyzing user positions and on-chain liquidity for each asset, and utilizing our supply and borrow cap methodology.

m.USDC
Untitled - 2023-09-20T120347.776
Untitled - 2023-09-20T120349.135
Resource: Chaos Labs Risk Platform

m.USDT
image
Untitled - 2023-09-20T120428.455
Resource: Chaos Labs Risk Platform

Utilizing our stress testing framework, we do not observe VaR while increasing the caps for USDC and USDT, as the main use case observed is looping the same asset to earn incentives. Given the on-chain liquidity observed over the past months, we recommend doubling the supply caps and setting the borrow caps at 90% of the supply cap.

WETH
Untitled - 2023-09-20T120552.754

Considering the limited on-chain liquidity of WETH, which is essential for supporting liquidations, we advise against further increasing the supply cap. Although small, our stress tests indicate an increase in VaR with higher caps. Therefore, we recommend contemplating increasing the supply cap only after observing an improvement in DEX liquidity.

However, given the current usage, we do recommend doubling the borrow cap from 90 to 180.
Untitled - 2023-09-20T120554.677
Untitled - 2023-09-20T120623.897

METIS

Untitled - 2023-09-20T120642.866

As Metis is listed as a non-collateral asset, we recommend doubling the current supply cap to 240K METIS. As there is a low demand for borrowing METIS, we do not recommend increasing the cap at this time.

m.DAI
We do not recommend increasing the supply and borrow cap of m.DAI as it currently represents nearly 60% of the total circulating supply on-chain.

Specification

Chain Asset Current Supply Cap Recommended Supply Cap Current Borrow Cap Recommended Borrow Cap
Metis m.USDC 1,200,000 2,400,000 1,200,000 2,150,000
Metis m.USDT 1,400,000 2,800,000 1,400,000 2,500,000
Metis WETH 300 No Change 90 180
Metis METIS 120,000 240,000 4,000 No Change

Next Steps

Once we receive feedback from @Gauntlet on the above recommendations, we will be able to move forward to implement these updates via the Risk Steward process.

1 Like

If the point of raising the supply and borrow caps is because users have looped assets, what is the point of this proposal?

This does not stop those same users from leveraging further and taking the newly increased cap space.

Position sizes should be limited. Not the amounts able to borrowed and lent.

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.