[ARFC] Onboard osGNO to Aave v3 Gnosis Instance

[ARFC] Onboard osGNO to Aave v3 Gnosis Instance

Author: ACI

Date: 2025-05-12


Summary

This proposal aims to Onboard osGNO, the Liquid Staking Token (LST) of StakeWise V3 into the GnosisMarket. By integrating osGNO, Aave users will be provided with additional liquidity and yield opportunities while supporting the growth of LSTs within the DeFi ecosystem on Gnosis Chain.

Previously another proposal was posted on 2024-08-08 but it didn’t pass due to Risk Service Providers recommendations. Nevertheless circumstances have changed.

Motivation

GNO is used for governance within the GnosisDAO and acts as a staking token for Gnosis Chain.

osGNO is a Liquid Staking Token (LST) representing GNO staked in StakeWise V3 on Gnosis Chain. It can be minted from any Vault created in StakeWise on Gnosis in order to make a user’s stake liquid. Users have the option of staking in one of the Vaults in the Marketplace to mint osGNO, creating their own Vault as a solo staker and minting osGNO from there, or purchasing osGNO directly on a DEX.

Creating Vaults and staking in them is a permissionless process on StakeWise, and so is access to osGNO. For additional protection, every minted osGNO has an excess backing of staked tokens, provided by the minters themselves.

osGNO increases in value relative to GNO as staking rewards accrue, it can be redeemed for the underlying GNO within Vaults using the redemption mechanism detailed here. If there are not sufficient liquid reserves available for redemption, there may be delays in unstaking and redeeming the osGNO for underlying GNO which could result in a temporary depeg.

osETH was recently added as collateral on Aave v3 Ethereum and has seen good adoption. In order to improve Aave’s marketshare on Gnosis Cchain, and support the Gnosis and StakeWise ecosystems it is proposed to also Onboard osGNO into Gnosis Market.

Proof of Liquidity and Deposit Commitments

Specification

Contract address: 0xF490c80aAE5f2616d3e3BDa2483E30C4CB21d1A0

Risk Parameters will be provided at ARFC Stage by Risk Service Providers.

Useful Links:

osGNO announcement post: Announcing the Launch of StakeWise V3 on Gnosis Chain | by StakeWise | Medium

osGNO Vaults: StakeWise | Vaults

TEMP CHECK Onboard osGNO to Aave V3 Gnosis

Disclaimer:

This proposal is powered by Skywards. ACI is not directly affiliated with StakeWise and did not receive compensation for creation this proposal.

ACI and some ACI team members are holders of GNO.

Next Steps

  1. If consensus is reached on this [ARFC], escalate this proposal to the Snapshot stage.
  2. If the ARFC snapshot outcome is YAE, publish an AIP vote for final confirmation and enforcement of the proposal

Copyright:

Copyright and related rights waived under CC0

Summary

This analysis covers the listing of osGNO within the Aave V3 Gnosis instance.

Techincal Overview

osGNO is a GNO LST created by Stakewise. The token represents GNO staked in “Vaults” and earns yield from validators. osGNO can be permissionlessly minted against any Gnosis Chain node. Unlike traditional LSTs, whereby the associated receipt token represents the pooled underlying at a 1:1 rate, minting osGNO requires a user to be overcollateralized in staked GNO with respect to his osGNO, at a ltvPercent ”minting threshold” of 90%. The rationale behind this is to leverage the excess backing of staked GNO to protect holders against slashing and poor performance risks from permissionless nodes. Effectively, this implies that the associated stakers in Vaults are exposed only to the performance of their respective Vault’s validators, while external holders of osGNO benefit from this GNO-denominated slashing loss buffer. To this effect, while stakers can only mint osGNO worth up to 90% of their staked GNO, they still retain rewards on 100% of their stake.

Protocol Incentives

In addition to the autonomy presented at the node operator/vault level, the protocol effectively creates and maintains a competitive marketplace between respective vault operators through economic (dis)incentive alignment at the protocol level. In addition to siloed slashing risks within respective vaults, the protocol enshrines a “fair exchange rate,” as referenced in the PriceFeed contract, which represents the weighted average APY across all vaults with feePercent ≤ 15%, acting as the effective reward baseline for all osGNO in circulation in ERC-4626 fashion. In the event that a user delegates to underperforming vaults, stemming from operator MEV extraction, substantial operator fees or suboptimal infra, the underlying LTV of the associated osETH vault positions can scale accordingly, as the effective number of shares collateralizing the underlying staked GNO is no longer in line with the protocol.

External Redemptions

If the value of a user’s osGNO position reaches 91.5% of the staked GNO value, any osGNO holder can redeem for GNO held in the vault, totally ordered with respect to the LTV of the position. The amount redeemed is calculated using the following equation.

image - 2024-12-23T173932.392

These third-party redemptions can only be conducted to bring a user’s health level back to 90%, minimizing the amount that stakers can lose, and are only profitable to perform under the assumption that the market price of osGNO is trading lower than the associated exchange rate, thereby implicitly aligning incentives to maintain protocol safety while explicitly contributing to peg reversion.

Liquidations

Furthermore, if the value of an osGNO position deviates further, past the enshrined liqThresholdPercent of 92% relative to the staked GNO, maintaining protocol solvency is no longer conditionally performed as a function of the negative market price deviation from the PriceFeed value, rather the position can be fully liquidated with a liqBonusPercent of 1% to the external actor.

Withdrawals

Burning osGNO and withdrawing staked GNO follows the underlying dynamics of the Gnosis exit queue, which, with a CHURN_LIMIT_QUOTIENT value of 212 as opposed to Ethereum’s 216 and 3.5x fewer validators, allows users to receive the underlying GNO exponentially faster than staked ETH, typically occurring in 24 hours.

Market Price Deviations

As a result of the mechanisms at play, we have observed periods where the asset was trading at a large premium relative to its exchange rate. In this sense, there exists an associated deterrent in capital efficiency such that arbitraging the upward deviation requires a user to adhere to the ltvPercent, capping the effective maximum upward deviation at ~1.11 osGNO/GNO, nearly akin to a CDP stablecoin such as LUSD. This effect, coupled with the relatively quick exit queue and redemption/liquidation mechanisms, makes it such that negative deviations will be short-lived, while positive deviations solely benefit the protocol.

The associated market dynamics overlayed with mint/burn events further exemplify this. Significant upward deviations lead to an implicit incentive to mint osGNO, as the effective APY realized will thus be higher. While an upward market price deviation can deter Stakewise redemptions and liquidations from occurring, the net accrual rate of the LTV is significantly reduced given by the rate difference between the lower-performing vault positions and the weighted average staking APY, thus we expect the market price to revert into a profitably liquidatable range within such a long timeframe. Moreover, as the LTV converges upward, the associated collateralizing stake relative to the total osGNO in circulation would thus be deteriorating, thereby resulting in the expected market price reacting accordingly.

Market Cap and Liquidity

The asset currently has a total supply of 29,400 osGNO ($4.4M), however it is worth noting that thanks to the use of Stakewise vaults, osGNO does not represent all of the GNO staked. The total supply of GNO staked with Stakewise, which can be minted as osGNO when there is demand for its usage within defi, is of 132,000 GHO.

The asset currently boast one significant DEX liquidity pool, the osGNO-GNO pool on Balancer, which, while its liquidity has dropped significantly since December 2024, is sufficent to support the listing of the asset.

LT, LTV, and LB

Given the asset’s somewhat limited liquidity on Gnosis, as well as its anticipated use case in leveraged yield generation strategies, we propose setting conservative parameters outside of the E-mode. Given the yield-bearing aspect of the asset, we recommend the introduction of an osGNO/GNO Liquid E-Mode to enable efficient leverage staking. In the E-Mode, we recommend the following parameters of 90%, 92.5%, and 2.5% for LTV, LT, and Liquidation Penalty, respectively.

Given the overcollateralized nature of osGNO, which enables upward deviations under a 1.11 GNO market price, liquidating osGHO/GHO positions on Aave becomes increasingly profitable during events of upward deviations. Hence, we consider the proposed 2.5% Liquidation Bonus to be sufficient to maintain a competitive and profitable liquidation market.

Supply and Borrow Caps

Given the safe techincal aspect of osGHO and its greater non circulating supply, we recommend setting the supply cap at 4x the liquidity available beneath the Liquidity Penalty of 2.5%. Hence, we recommend a supply cap of 32,000 osGNO.

Oracle

We recommend using the GNO/USD oracle augmented with the exchange rate contained in Stakewise’s PriceFeed contract.

CAPO Configuration

Following the methodology in this post, we recommend using a 14-day MINIMUM_SNAPSHOT_DELAY and a maxYearlyRatioGrowthPercent of 13.01%.

maxYearlyRatioGrowthPercent ratioReferenceTime MINIMUM_SNAPSHOT_DELAY
13.01% monthly 14 days

Specification

Parameter Value
Asset osGNO
Isolation Mode N/A
Borrowable No
Collateral Enabled Yes
Supply Cap 32,000
Borrow Cap -
Debt Ceiling -
LTV 40%
LT 45%
Liquidation Bonus 10%
Liquidation Protocol Fee 10%
Variable Base -
Variable Slope1 -
Variable Slope2 -
Uoptimal -
Reserve Factor -
Stable Borrowing Disabled
Flashloanable Yes
Siloed Borrowing No
Borrowable in Isolation No

E-Mode Specifications

Parameter Value Value
Asset osGNO GNO
Collateral Yes No
Borrowable No Yes
Max LTV 90% -
Liquidation Threshold 92.5% -
Liquidation Bonus 2.50% -

Disclaimer

Chaos Labs has not been compensated by any third party for publishing this ARFC.

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0

Summary

LlamaRisk supports the onboarding of osGNO to the Aave V3 Gnosis Instance. The asset presents limited risks to the protocol, primarily from concentrated DEX liquidity, an inactive bug bounty program, and the absence of a timelock on contract upgrades. Nearly all osGNO liquidity on Gnosis resides in the Balancer osGNO/GNO-BPT pool, with the majority of liquidity provided by a single entity. This concentration introduces the risk of a liquidity crunch if the LP or counterparty withdraws, potentially impairing liquidations and increasing the risk of bad debt.

Additionally, osGNO relies on an off-chain Oracle Network composed of 11 elected participants to manage validator operations. While the StakeWise team asserts that Oracle processes are fully automated without manual intervention, this off-chain dependency still constitutes an operational risk. Nevertheless, osGNO is an overcollateralized LST with built-in slashing protection via excess GNO backing, which helps mitigate validator-related losses. Despite the outlined concerns, osGNO demonstrates low overall market risk.

Collateral Risk Assessment

1. Asset Fundamental Characteristics

1.1 Asset

osGNO is a liquid staking token for GNO on Gnosis, introduced by StakeWise and deployed at the address 0xF490c80aAE5f2616d3e3BDa2483E30C4CB21d1A0. It represents GNO staked in StakeWise Vaults and is overcollateralized to provide a buffer against slashing risks, unlike traditional LSTs that maintain a 1:1 backing with the underlying token.

As of May 15, 2025, osGNO has a circulating supply of 29,529 on Gnosis, with a market capitalization of $4.23M. The token was deployed on July 3, 2024, and offers 6.9% APY currently.

1.2 Architecture

The main components of the StakeWise protocol are Vaults, osGNO token, and Oracles. osGNO is an ERC-20 token that accrues GNO staking rewards over time and is fully backed by staked GNO in validators managed by Vaults. osGNO is redeemable for GNO as long as Vault’s collateral remains healthy. Vaults are permissionless, non-custodial, and isolated staking pools interacting with Gnosis nodes to enable staking on customizable terms. To ensure secure and decentralized operations, an off-chain Oracle network is employed. These Oracles do not have custody over funds but are responsible for registering validators, calculating rewards, and updating the blockchain with validator-related events such as entries and exits.

As of now, a total of 153.4K GNO has been staked through StakeWise by 568 participants. The protocol charges a 5% fee on the staking rewards earned through osGNO, which is collected by the StakeWise DAO Treasury Multisig.


Source: Top GNO Staking Vaults, StakeWise, May 15, 2025

Minting
osGNO can be minted permissionlessly by users who stake GNO in Vaults. Each token minted must be backed by staked GNO in active validators. The amount of osGNO a user can mint depends on the value of their stake and the excess backing threshold determined by the DAO. Most Vaults operate at a 90% LTV ratio, meaning a staker can mint osGNO worth up to 90% of their deposited GNO. However, this threshold can be increased to 99.95% for certain Vaults if the operator meets specific requirements, i.e., locking a 1M SWISE bond in a DAO-controlled address. These Vaults, once approved, allow users to mint osGNO almost equal to the full value of their staked GNO. The over-collateralization in 90% LTV Vaults provides a safety margin in case of slashing or other validator losses, ensuring osGNO remains fully backed. In contrast, the 99.95% LTV Vaults rely on the SWISE bond for risk mitigation rather than excess GNO.

Burning
To maintain protocol health, StakeWise continuously monitors the ratio of minted osGNO to the value of the underlying staked GNO, a metric known as position health. For 90% of LTV Vaults, this health is categorized as Healthy (below 90%), Moderate (90–91%), Risky (91–92%), and Unhealthy (above 92%). When a position crosses the 91.5% redemption threshold, anyone can initiate a partial burn of the user’s osGNO to return the position to a healthy level. In 99.95% LTV Vaults, user positions are always considered healthy because the osGNO annual yield aligns with the lowest-yielding 99.9% LTV Vault, thereby avoiding the need for forced burns. To fully unstake from any Vault, a user must burn the entire amount of osGNO. Burning only a portion of it allows for only partial withdrawal, ensuring the Vault maintains adequate backing.

Redemption
When a user initiates unstaking, the protocol attempts to fulfill the request using any unbonded GNO available in the Vault. Unbonded GNO refers to amounts less than 1 GNO from deposits or rewards in the Vault that cannot be staked and, therefore, do not earn rewards. If the unbonded balance is insufficient, the protocol exits validators to release the necessary amount of GNO. This process introduces a delay based on the current length of the exit queue on the Beacon Chain. Users stop earning staking rewards once they enter the queue, even though they may not have received their GNO yet. Importantly, redemptions incur no fees and have no negative economic impact on other Vault participants.

1.3 Tokenomics

The total supply of osGNO is not fixed, and users can permissionlessly mint it against any Gnosis Chain node. 280 unique addresses hold osGNO on Gnosis.

1.3.1 Token Holder Concentration


Source: osGNO Top 100 Token Holders, GnosisScan, May 15, 2025

The top 5 holders of osGNO are:

The top 10 holders collectively own 63.25% of osGNO’s total supply.

2. Market Risk

2.1 Liquidity


Source: osGNO/GNO Swap Liquidity, DeFiLlama, May 15, 2025

Users can swap osGNO worth up to $1.32M (9118 osGNO) for GNO within a slippage of 10%.

2.1.1 Liquidity Venue Concentration


Source: osGNO Liquidity Pools on Gnosis, GeckoTerminal, May 15, 2025

Most osGNO liquidity on Gnosis is held within the Balancer V2 osGNO/GNO-BPT ($2.45M TVL) pool.

2.1.2 DEX LP Concentration

The liquidity of osGNO in the Balancer osGNO/GNO-BPT is highly concentrated among a few users. 68.94% of the pool’s liquidity is supplied by a 3/10 Safe Multisig. The remainder of the liquidity is supplied by Aura Finance.

2.2 Volatility


Source: osGNO/GNO Secondary Market Rate, GeckoTerminal, May 15, 2025

This year, osGNO’s secondary market price has closely tracked its exchange rate, showing no significant deviations. Between October and December 2024, it traded at a premium. However, as market liquidity improved, the price quickly reverted to the correct exchange rate and has remained stable with minimal volatility.

2.3 Exchanges

osGNO is exclusively traded on DEXs and is not currently listed on any centralized exchange.

2.4 Growth


Source: osGNO Circulating Supply on Gnosis, Dune, May 15, 2025

The circulating supply of osGNO on Gnosis has steadily increased since its deployment last year. Year-to-date, it has grown by approximately 58%, reaching a current total of 29,529 osGNO.

3. Technological Risk

3.1 Smart Contract Risk

StakeWise V3’s OsToken contract handles the core logic for osGNO token. These contracts have undergone independent audits by multiple third-party security firms, and the findings were as follows:

  • Sigma Prime (September 2024): 3 low and 1 informational
  • Sigma Prime (June 2024): 1 critical, 2 medium, 5 low, and 4 informational
  • Sigma Prime (August 2023): 2 critical, 5 high, 1 medium, 3 low, and 10 informational
  • Halborn (July 2023): 1 medium and 2 low
  • Halborn (April 2023): 1 high and 3 low

All of the issues were either resolved or acknowledged by the StakeWise team.

3.2 Bug Bounty Program

StakeWise does not offer a bug bounty program for its Gnosis Chain smart contracts. Its active $200K Immunefi bug bounty program covers only the Ethereum contracts.

3.3 Price Feed Risk

Chainlink has a GNO/USD price feed live on Gnosis Chain Mainnet. It can be used with StakeWise’s internal PriceFeed contract’s osGNO/GNO exchange rate to price osGNO on Aave V3 Gnosis markets.

The PriceFeed contract reflects the fair osGNO exchange rate by calling the getRate function. This data is also used for internal vault and token operations by OsTokenVaultController.

3.4 Dependency Risk

Off-chain Oracles
StakeWise V3 relies on an off-chain component called Oracles to fetch staking reward data from the Beacon Chain and to trigger validator registration and exit processes. These Oracles must remain highly available and sufficiently decentralized to ensure seamless operation. To this end, the StakeWise DAO has elected 11 participants to perform oracle duties, with a 7/11 threshold required for consensus. The current oracle network participants on Gnosis include Chorus One and Stake.fish, Telekom, Finoa Consensus Services, Bitfly, SenseiNode, Gateway.fm, the Gnosis Chain team, Axol.io, DSRV, and the StakeWise development team. Oracle operations are fully automated using Oracle software developed by the StakeWise team, with no manual intervention required.

4. Counterparty Risk

4.1 Governance and Regulatory Risk

StakeWise’s Terms of Service, read together with the osGNO User Agreement, lay down the contractual architecture that governs the staking of GNO tokens through the StakeWise protocol.

Under these documents, osGNO is a freely transferable ERC-20 “cryptographic receipt” token that mirrors the holder’s proprietary interest in the staked GNO. The possession of osGNO evidences an immediate entitlement to the underlying principal and any network-generated rewards, subject only to a deduction for slashing events. Because the token is divisible and may be conveyed inter vivos without restriction, any assignment of osGNO automatically passes legal and beneficial ownership of the equivalent quantity of staked GNO to the transferee.

StakeWise, for its part, is at pains to describe its role in strictly technical terms, expressly disavowing any characterization as broker, dealer, exchange, investment adviser, custodian, or other regulated financial intermediary. The contractual language is unambiguous: holders of osGNO remain the sole legal and beneficial owners of the related staked assets. StakeWise undertakes no fiduciary or custodial duties beyond the provision of validator-operation services.

Risk allocation is similarly explicit. All economic and operational hazards—including the imposition of slashing penalties by the Gnosis Chain—are contractually borne by the user. Should a penalty be levied, each unit of osGNO will correspondingly redeem for a proportionately diminished amount of GNO, thereby passing the entire downside to the token holder in real-time.

Eligibility provisions reinforce the compliance posture of the protocol. A user must have reached the age of majority in the relevant jurisdiction—never less than eighteen years—and must not be physically present in or ordinarily resident within any territory subject to comprehensive sanctions, including but not limited to Belarus, Cuba, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Iran, North Korea, Syria, or any other jurisdiction listed in the Terms of Service. Moreover, an applicant must not appear on the U.S. Department of the Treasury’s OFAC sanctions lists or the denied persons, entity, or unverified lists maintained by the Bureau of Industry and Security and must affirmatively warrant the absence of any such designation before interacting with the protocol.

Finally, several substantive provisions underscore osGNO’s nature as a pure receipt token. The agreements make clear that osGNO confers direct title to identifiable staked GNO, not a pro-rata share in a collective investment enterprise. They provide that the token may be transferred to any ERC-20-compatible wallet on the Gnosis Chain, with every transfer affecting a concomitant transfer of the economic benefits and burdens attached to the underlying stake. They confirm that each token is fractionable, permitting granular allocation of ownership. These clauses ensure a seamless pass-through of rewards and penalties, preserving the one-to-one correspondence between the receipt token and the staked asset it represents.

The juridical status of the osGNO receipt-token architecture remains largely untested before courts in any major forum, and its ultimate characterization is likely to pivot on the specific statutory and case-law matrix of each jurisdiction.

Creative Tech Free Zone Co. DBA “StakeWise” —has been incorporated in the United Arab Emirates; however, the public record does not specify the particular free-zone authority or on-shore regulator responsible for its licensing and prudential oversight. Without clarity on whether the company falls under, for example, the Dubai Multi Commodities Centre, the Abu Dhabi Global Market, the Dubai International Financial Centre, or another economic zone, it is impossible to map with precision the statutory provisions, rulebooks, and supervisory expectations governing its conduct of business.

The UAE has not promulgated a uniform statute devoted to staking services. Regulatory competence is fragmented among multiple federal and emirate-level bodies—each with its rulebook, sandbox guidance, and licensing taxonomy—so the applicable legal regime turns on the geographic locus of incorporation or service delivery.

Pending receipt of documentary evidence from the StakeWise team—such as constitutional documents, regulatory licenses, exemptions, or no-action assurances—the working assumption must be that the protocol’s non-custodial design, standing alone, does not appear to trigger an extant licensing requirement under current UAE laws.

4.2 Access Control Risk

4.2.1 Contract Modification Options

Here are the controlling wallets:

  • Multisig A: 4/7 Safe multisig, owner of most contracts listed in architecture and also acts as DAO treasury that collects osGNO fees.
  • Multisig B: 1/2 Safe multisig, admin of the genesis vault.

The osGNO architecture is powered by the following contracts:

4.2.2 Timelock Duration and Function

No timelock is configured on upgrades for any of the contracts mentioned above.

4.2.3 Multisig Threshold / Signer identity

All the major contracts in osGNO architecture are governed by the Multisig A (a 4/7 Safe), which is the StakeWise DAO Treasury. The current elected committee members are:

Name Address
Ali Nuraldin 0x7E36F1fF26cffD6906c11Cd7Eca5f6E993Ba6CE3
Andreas Dittrich 0xc0c9707B552C6970f66Ab91D563Bf9b6048E9da6
Auryn Macmillan 0x9Aa6Db877742aD8D8c7fE209F561fbd2bE19D5F4
Dmitri Tsumak 0x61B01a33Aea3e827B3941Ab097778bd3FA48a332
Gleb Dudka 0xC46e791d4fB1207fAB8Cb0e44889127138539c69
Mikko Ohtamaa 0x9cC9c3de8e710781983a65b90B7efEaaD2D3D7D8
Otto de Voogd 0x1C86117156Ba31b5d62f02eB56bE9aC5a06610d3

Note: This assessment follows the LLR-Aave Framework, a comprehensive methodology for asset onboarding and parameterization in Aave V3. This framework is continuously updated and available here.

Aave V3 Specific Parameters

We support the osGNO parameters and E-mode configuration proposed by @ChaosLabs.

Price feed Recommendation

We recommend pricing osGNO on Aave using StakeWise’s internal osGNO/GNO exchange rate in combination with Chainlink’s GNO/USD price feed along with the CAPO configurations suggested by @ChaosLabs to price the asset safely for the Aave market.

Disclaimer

This review was independently prepared by LlamaRisk, a community-led decentralized organization funded in part by the Aave DAO. LlamaRisk is not directly affiliated with the protocol(s) reviewed in this assessment and did not receive any compensation from the protocol(s) or their affiliated entities for this work.

The information provided should not be construed as legal, financial, tax, or professional advice.